Update on the Rennison book: it's tedious and a chore to finish. This is supposed to be a biography of Sherlock Holmes. Where's the fun and cleverness and fannishness? The last half of the book, post FINA, was dull and pointless. On the Hiatus, Rennison says that Holmes did go to Tibet and all that, as undercover intelligence work for Mycroft. Completely glossing over Holmes's stupid reasons for faking his death. Then he keeps us telling us about other historical people who made the same trips to Khartoum, etc. What does that matter? Eventually Holmes returns to London, and we go through various cases in Baker Street. (It's a rough chronology scattered through the book, never gathered clearly into a list, and never justified.)
Then Rennison says that Watson did get married a second time, but has no speculation on who the lady is. Then he says that Holmes didn't really retire in 1903 but kept working various cases, including joining Doyle on his George Edalji case. Plus he secretly continued his spywork in the early days of MI6, leading up to "His Last Bow" of course. Rennison just keeps saying "this happened, then that happened, and then, and then..." but never stops to say WHY any of this is happening. Why did Holmes decide to pretend to retire? Why the fuck does he care about spywork instead of detective cases? Why did he eventually retire to Sussex? Rennison even says that Holmes becomes involved in stage and film adaptations of Watson's stories, and that Doyle is handling licensing rights. He claims that Holmes is interested in this due to his lifelong love of theatre, but why should he like plays based on his life, when he complained so bitterly about Watson's stories based on his life?
I don't get why Rennison thinks namedropping other famous Victorians and famous crimes should make any of this interesting. I need to see Holmes and Watson's motivations and their feelings about events. I need to see their relationship, even if the author thinks they're only friends. But no, this guy just claims that Holmes also became friends with Doyle and interacted with him independently of Watson. The book covers Doyle's Spiritualism and his getting fooled by the fairy photos, but like, there's no impact on the Holmes and Watson story. This pseudobiography started out fine, but it's just a real disappointment in the end. As I said, Rennison includes a Sherlockian bibliography at the end, but he doesn't cite his sources for any of his theories, so I don't know where he got anything from. I don't know which parts are fictional, and which parts are nuggets pulled from real history. Useless.